Would you rather have a subscriber or a friend?

21st September 2011 by Emily20

Facebook recently introduced the ‘subscribe button‘ to all personal accounts that choose to switch it on. In a nutshell, it’s a way of allowing strangers to form a one way relationship with your profile. They can click ‘subscribe’ to receive any updates you post marked ‘public’, whereas any updates marked ‘friends’ will only be revealed to those on your friends list, as normal.

The reaction to this development has so far been mixed. Some have welcomed it, others have been indifferent but made obvious comparisons to the similar functionality offered by Google+ and Twitter, while others still have questioned the value of forming one-way relationships on Facebook.

Yesterday, in a small survey of 13 very active social media users, I asked:

Would you rather have a connection or a subscriber?

    1. Connection (i.e. ‘friend’)
    2. It’s not that simple
    3. Subscriber

76% said friend, 24% said ‘it’s not that simple’, but no one said they would prefer a subscriber. Below, respondents expand on their reasoning.

In the friend camp:

Subscriber feels more stalkerish to me so I’m saying friend – Mark Leary

Friend. Mind you if I were still a ruthless PR practitioner I might like both – Jane Crofts

Friend. My intuition is that the back-and-forth of a connection is better than the send-and-receive of a subscriber – David Bennett

Friend. But I’d much prefer a client 😉 – Matt Anderson

In the ‘it’s not that simple camp’:

I think both have value – it depends on how you use your FB account. If you only accept family and true friends then it’s possible you don’t care about subscribers, because you don’t post business stuff. If you accept business connections too (as I do) then the subscriber option becomes more valid. People who may not want to connect as friends can subscribe and receive my updates. Although personally I’d prefer it if they just liked my business page, where they’ll get business updates and not ‘ooh Olivia just did a wee in the potty’ type stuff – Nikki Pilkington

People have always been able to subscribe – all they had to do was send a friend request (which is then ignored) and public updates still appear in their feed. So technically if you are posting public updates then why not allow people to subscribe? I’ll have friends, colleagues and connections as friends (in different lists of course) but let anyone to subscribe to my public updates – it just makes sense – David Clare

What do you think? Friend of subscriber? And have you turned the subscriber option on?


20 comments

  • Andrew Beeken

    21st September 2011 at 8:24 am

    I think I’m in the latter camp. I personally welcome this as I’ve often had discussions around the Local Govt community regarding how we can publicise ourselves on Facebook – we all want to be on there as there is a massive audience, but would people REALLY want to “friend” their local council?

    Changing that option to “subscribe” would certainly remove that stigma – if only Facebook would officially allow business accounts! Perhaps this is the first step along that road?

    Reply

  • Andrew Beeken

    21st September 2011 at 8:24 am

    I think I’m in the latter camp. I personally welcome this as I’ve often had discussions around the Local Govt community regarding how we can publicise ourselves on Facebook – we all want to be on there as there is a massive audience, but would people REALLY want to “friend” their local council?

    Changing that option to “subscribe” would certainly remove that stigma – if only Facebook would officially allow business accounts! Perhaps this is the first step along that road?

    Reply

  • Jan Minihane

    21st September 2011 at 8:31 am

    I can’t help thinking it’s come too late – if it had always been around I would probably have encouraged people I didn’t know well to subscribe (and then convert some to friends over time) – I have 100’s of ‘friends’ on Facebook that I’ve had to put into lists to protect my privacy where appropriate. Now it just feels like it’s ‘something else’ to manage (yawn)?

    Reply

  • Jan Minihane

    21st September 2011 at 8:31 am

    I can’t help thinking it’s come too late – if it had always been around I would probably have encouraged people I didn’t know well to subscribe (and then convert some to friends over time) – I have 100’s of ‘friends’ on Facebook that I’ve had to put into lists to protect my privacy where appropriate. Now it just feels like it’s ‘something else’ to manage (yawn)?

    Reply

  • David Bennett

    21st September 2011 at 9:09 am

    What David Clare said is interesting. I didn’t know that “People have always been able to subscribe – all they had to do was send a friend request (which is then ignored) and public updates still appear in their feed.”

    I guess that may have all changed now with the new rules, system, opportunities, heaven, or whatever FB is calling it.

    As I said recently in this context:

    I am saved from being irritated by all these changes and rules by letting them drift away into the aether where I hope they land in the room in FB headquarters where they make them, and ruin the day of the people who sit there attempting to make my life more difficult.

    Reply

    • David Clare

      21st September 2011 at 6:16 pm

      Just to clarify – the ability to ‘informally subscribe’, shall we say, was not an actual ‘feature’. Just a strange consequence of asking someone to be your friend and them ignoring you. It is a bit weird, especially since the person did not want to be your friend… but then again you were only shown their public updates. I’m unsure whether it still works – will have to check up on those who don’t want to be friends 😉

      Reply

      • Emily

        21st September 2011 at 6:20 pm

        I saw this happening too. Confusing!

        Reply

      • David Bennett

        21st September 2011 at 6:29 pm

        Thanks, David. I understood what you meant – that it was a something the system threw up, rather than an intentionally designed feature.

        Reply

  • David Bennett

    21st September 2011 at 9:09 am

    What David Clare said is interesting. I didn’t know that “People have always been able to subscribe – all they had to do was send a friend request (which is then ignored) and public updates still appear in their feed.”

    I guess that may have all changed now with the new rules, system, opportunities, heaven, or whatever FB is calling it.

    As I said recently in this context:

    I am saved from being irritated by all these changes and rules by letting them drift away into the aether where I hope they land in the room in FB headquarters where they make them, and ruin the day of the people who sit there attempting to make my life more difficult.

    Reply

    • David Clare

      21st September 2011 at 6:16 pm

      Just to clarify – the ability to ‘informally subscribe’, shall we say, was not an actual ‘feature’. Just a strange consequence of asking someone to be your friend and them ignoring you. It is a bit weird, especially since the person did not want to be your friend… but then again you were only shown their public updates. I’m unsure whether it still works – will have to check up on those who don’t want to be friends 😉

      Reply

      • Emily

        21st September 2011 at 6:20 pm

        I saw this happening too. Confusing!

        Reply

      • David Bennett

        21st September 2011 at 6:29 pm

        Thanks, David. I understood what you meant – that it was a something the system threw up, rather than an intentionally designed feature.

        Reply

  • Steven Healey

    21st September 2011 at 10:06 am

    Subscribing has the same function as the Google + public post , everyone can see your posts .

    Friends are more valued , subscribers overcome the count limit on Friends , and you can take a closer look at subscribers then decided whether to connect.

    Reply

  • Steven Healey

    21st September 2011 at 10:06 am

    Subscribing has the same function as the Google + public post , everyone can see your posts .

    Friends are more valued , subscribers overcome the count limit on Friends , and you can take a closer look at subscribers then decided whether to connect.

    Reply

  • Mr Matt Anderson

    21st September 2011 at 1:01 pm

    I am not sure what Facebook is up to with this function, surely if you want to keep in touch with someone you would be their friend? Also as a marketeer I would just monitor Facebook statuses with Ubervu etc anyway rather than onerously subscribing to other Facebook feeds. I guess the only gap in the market is for personalities who do not have a Facebook page as such. As a brand I would rather have an open dialogue with customers or potential clients rather than remotely subscribing them. If you want to subscribe to me by the way http://www.facebook.com/prbristolblog but you probably just want to follow me on Twitter in any case?

    Reply

  • Mr Matt Anderson

    21st September 2011 at 1:01 pm

    I am not sure what Facebook is up to with this function, surely if you want to keep in touch with someone you would be their friend? Also as a marketeer I would just monitor Facebook statuses with Ubervu etc anyway rather than onerously subscribing to other Facebook feeds. I guess the only gap in the market is for personalities who do not have a Facebook page as such. As a brand I would rather have an open dialogue with customers or potential clients rather than remotely subscribing them. If you want to subscribe to me by the way http://www.facebook.com/prbristolblog but you probably just want to follow me on Twitter in any case?

    Reply

  • David Clare

    21st September 2011 at 6:13 pm

    Really interesting to see everyone’s point of view. Thankfully the subscribe feature does no harm to those that are against, as you must opt in to let people subscribe to you. Personally I like the feature and will use both (as stated in my comment) – it will be interesting to see if this has any impact on Twitter, but that seems quite far down the line.

    Reply

    • Emily

      21st September 2011 at 6:19 pm

      Good point, David – it’s a good thing that it’s opt in. Facebook has obviously learned from past mistakes!

      Reply

  • David Clare

    21st September 2011 at 6:13 pm

    Really interesting to see everyone’s point of view. Thankfully the subscribe feature does no harm to those that are against, as you must opt in to let people subscribe to you. Personally I like the feature and will use both (as stated in my comment) – it will be interesting to see if this has any impact on Twitter, but that seems quite far down the line.

    Reply

    • Emily

      21st September 2011 at 6:19 pm

      Good point, David – it’s a good thing that it’s opt in. Facebook has obviously learned from past mistakes!

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.