Lincoln City v Barcelona: A battle of the brands

28th February 2012 by Matt16

Last week’s launch of the new ‘brand Lincoln’ was a well-attended and well-covered event, but in the aftermath, has everyone missed the point? Work on creating Lincoln’s brand really starts now.

What was unveiled last week was a logo and some ideas of how it could feature in a promotional campaign. The people, businesses and organisations that reside and work here will ultimately be responsible for creating and nurturing ‘brand Lincoln’.

Whether you like the new logo is irrelevant. It’s here. It will be used. It has to be adopted by people and organisations if it is to succeed. And it has to succeed as the intentions behind it – putting Lincoln on the tourism map and raising the profile of the city – are vital. Tourism, especially in the era of the ‘staycation’, can play a significant role in boosting the local economy.

I went to Barcelona last September. I loved it. Firstly, there was so much to do. Secondly and most importantly, the people I met – from waiters, police officers, shop assistants, hotel staff and people in the street (who pointed us in the right direction) were a delight – they were friendly, helpful and smiling. That’s the brand. The emotional connection they created.

In some respects, Barcelona and Lincoln aren’t too far apart (especially, if you take away the climate and the football clubs). No, really! Both have magnificent cathedrals, both have amazing architecture, both have great museums and art galleries; restaurants, bars, concert halls and great local produce. Visit Lincoln needs to find a way of recreating Barcelona in the East Midlands.

A brand goes much deeper than a logo. A brand is a set of associations that an existing or potential customer has of a company, product, service, individual or in this case, a place. These associations can be the result of your own efforts and actively promoted through marketing and corporate identity. Branding also reflects your customers’ experiences of your business and affects every interaction you have with your customers and stakeholders.

The intelligent use of design, advertising, marketing, service proposition and corporate culture can all help to generate associations in people’s minds that will benefit your organisation.

Visit Lincoln now has an agreed and widely accepted identity. What the organisation needs to do now is encourage all of the attractions, shops, restaurants, theatres, concert halls and nightclubs to help create the brand by delivering an engaging and consistent experience.

Am I right, am I wrong? Lincoln is beginning to think like a brand. It has a logo. Now people need to adopt it and create the brand. What makes us different and more attractive to visitors than Cambridge or York? Why come to Lincoln? What does Lincoln do differently and more seductively than other cathedral cities? That’s what needs to be worked on next – starting now.


16 comments

  • Gary Marshall

    29th February 2012 at 1:04 pm

    The strategy of the brand and/or understanding needs to have already been sorted before the logo is done. If work on the brand is just starting now its too late sadly.

    The logo can’t just be handed out to every establishment to slap on their marketing without a clear vision of what it is trying to achieve.

    When launching a brand its far more important to express the values and vision than show a logo, that way people may get more emotional attached to it and start to shout about it.

    Reply

      • Gary Marshall

        29th February 2012 at 4:43 pm

        Hi Samantha

        Thanks for those, much appreciated, though technically speaking they are brand identity guidelines and like I mentioned previously more to do with helping marketing.

        Reading earlier press releases I’m trying to see how a new logo is going to bring in an extra 1.2 million visitors thats been mentioned, agree a clear proposition helps but also WHY will more people want to come here and not spend their money elsewhere. Is there a bigger market? A different market? What do you need to do to pull them away from similar places like York, Bath etc?

        What I’m getting at is if nothing has changed from before (apart from a new logo) then you will get the same results.

        Reply

        • John Dowling

          2nd March 2012 at 1:43 pm

          Regarding Matt’s post above, it mentions what we all know and what we want to hear but putting into practice is another matter, especially for Visit Lincoln. 

          I too have read the same books with all the design jargon and bullshit attached, attended the same seminars and listened to all kinds of experts. I have worked for and been taught by some of the best designers/companies in the world and the more I see and the more I read, the more I realise that all Visit Lincoln have is a logo and not a brand.

          People shouldn’t be afraid to speak up and have an opinion and not worry about challenging the very people who may or may not employ them in the future. I’m amazed at how the design community (particularly in Lincoln and the surrounding areas) have stayed silent or at least half hearteningly endorsed the new marque.

          I agree with Gary, all we have is a logo which will be placed in the bottom right hand corner of a publication or ad, just like the illustrations in the guidelines. This is neither intelligent nor a brand.

          I too am looking forward to see how it develops into a brand and how it could ‘boost the city of Lincoln’s economy by 70million a year by 2020’.

          Reply

        • Mark

          4th March 2012 at 2:45 pm

          Hi Gary, thank you for your input regarding the future development of the Lincoln brand. As Chairman and founder member of the VLP I am very execited by the enthusiasm within the City to work together and ensure Lincoln is promoted in a coherent manner.

          I am confident that Lincoln will blosom in the near future and look forward to working with all stakeholders, over the next few months, to develop a realistic Densination Management Plan to take us to the next level.

          Reply

          • Gary Marshall

            5th March 2012 at 12:33 pm

            Hi Mark

            Hope you are well. As Chairman I would expect nothing less than enthusiasm from you BUT I’m not doubting that from you or any shareholder, what I’m stating is you are creating a marketing campaign, not a brand!

  • Gary Marshall

    29th February 2012 at 1:04 pm

    The strategy of the brand and/or understanding needs to have already been sorted before the logo is done. If work on the brand is just starting now its too late sadly.

    The logo can’t just be handed out to every establishment to slap on their marketing without a clear vision of what it is trying to achieve.

    When launching a brand its far more important to express the values and vision than show a logo, that way people may get more emotional attached to it and start to shout about it.

    Reply

      • Gary Marshall

        29th February 2012 at 4:43 pm

        Hi Samantha

        Thanks for those, much appreciated, though technically speaking they are brand identity guidelines and like I mentioned previously more to do with helping marketing.

        Reading earlier press releases I’m trying to see how a new logo is going to bring in an extra 1.2 million visitors thats been mentioned, agree a clear proposition helps but also WHY will more people want to come here and not spend their money elsewhere. Is there a bigger market? A different market? What do you need to do to pull them away from similar places like York, Bath etc?

        What I’m getting at is if nothing has changed from before (apart from a new logo) then you will get the same results.

        Reply

        • John Dowling

          2nd March 2012 at 1:43 pm

          Regarding Matt’s post above, it mentions what we all know and what we want to hear but putting into practice is another matter, especially for Visit Lincoln. 

          I too have read the same books with all the design jargon and bullshit attached, attended the same seminars and listened to all kinds of experts. I have worked for and been taught by some of the best designers/companies in the world and the more I see and the more I read, the more I realise that all Visit Lincoln have is a logo and not a brand.

          People shouldn’t be afraid to speak up and have an opinion and not worry about challenging the very people who may or may not employ them in the future. I’m amazed at how the design community (particularly in Lincoln and the surrounding areas) have stayed silent or at least half hearteningly endorsed the new marque.

          I agree with Gary, all we have is a logo which will be placed in the bottom right hand corner of a publication or ad, just like the illustrations in the guidelines. This is neither intelligent nor a brand.

          I too am looking forward to see how it develops into a brand and how it could ‘boost the city of Lincoln’s economy by 70million a year by 2020’.

          Reply

        • Mark

          4th March 2012 at 2:45 pm

          Hi Gary, thank you for your input regarding the future development of the Lincoln brand. As Chairman and founder member of the VLP I am very execited by the enthusiasm within the City to work together and ensure Lincoln is promoted in a coherent manner.

          I am confident that Lincoln will blosom in the near future and look forward to working with all stakeholders, over the next few months, to develop a realistic Densination Management Plan to take us to the next level.

          Reply

          • Gary Marshall

            5th March 2012 at 12:33 pm

            Hi Mark

            Hope you are well. As Chairman I would expect nothing less than enthusiasm from you BUT I’m not doubting that from you or any shareholder, what I’m stating is you are creating a marketing campaign, not a brand!

  • Emma Tatlow

    1st March 2012 at 10:20 am

    Good to see this is causing some interest and comments. I can assure you this is not just a logo – it is deeper than that and a considerable amount of research has gone into this. The brand has been created following the development of a business plan and marketing strategy, and will evolve over time. And as Matt says in the blog this brand won’t make a place but it will act as the glue that brings the identity of Lincoln together over time.

    Messages such as the best food county, pride in Lincolnshire will come out in campaign activity.

    There is a considerable amount of product development in Lincoln currently – with increased accommodation stock, the Heritage Skilss Centre, potential £18m investment in the Castle and our views and vision are long term. The Visit Lincoln Partnership has sucessfully managed to bring the key stakeholders in the city around one table to take this forward to ensure we do maximise Lincoln’s potential as a visitor destination. The first time this has happened in this way.

    I’ll look forward to sharing updates so you will see how we are adding value and making a difference to Lincoln.

    Emma Tatlow, Visit Lincoln Partnership Manager

    Reply

    • Gary Marshall

      1st March 2012 at 3:42 pm

      Hi Emma

      So looking through the brand identity guidelines you are being a blend of old and new, historic and modern, a city of contrast. All things to all people? That’s marketing, not a brand I have to say.

      A brand is built on a very narrow focus and a clear set of principles, so the brand launch should be about the vision, Lincoln’s authenticity, differentiation to competitors, a core message and not a set of logo’s and strap lines etc.

      Though totally agree no brand can be built without the CEO and so getting all the key stakeholders together is critical but what I mentioned above needs to be fed to the market (households, local businesses etc), not the guidelines; so people can FEEL the brand.

      A brand is embraced.

      I look forward to seeing the development. 

      Reply

  • Emma Tatlow

    1st March 2012 at 10:20 am

    Good to see this is causing some interest and comments. I can assure you this is not just a logo – it is deeper than that and a considerable amount of research has gone into this. The brand has been created following the development of a business plan and marketing strategy, and will evolve over time. And as Matt says in the blog this brand won’t make a place but it will act as the glue that brings the identity of Lincoln together over time.

    Messages such as the best food county, pride in Lincolnshire will come out in campaign activity.

    There is a considerable amount of product development in Lincoln currently – with increased accommodation stock, the Heritage Skilss Centre, potential £18m investment in the Castle and our views and vision are long term. The Visit Lincoln Partnership has sucessfully managed to bring the key stakeholders in the city around one table to take this forward to ensure we do maximise Lincoln’s potential as a visitor destination. The first time this has happened in this way.

    I’ll look forward to sharing updates so you will see how we are adding value and making a difference to Lincoln.

    Emma Tatlow, Visit Lincoln Partnership Manager

    Reply

    • Gary Marshall

      1st March 2012 at 3:42 pm

      Hi Emma

      So looking through the brand identity guidelines you are being a blend of old and new, historic and modern, a city of contrast. All things to all people? That’s marketing, not a brand I have to say.

      A brand is built on a very narrow focus and a clear set of principles, so the brand launch should be about the vision, Lincoln’s authenticity, differentiation to competitors, a core message and not a set of logo’s and strap lines etc.

      Though totally agree no brand can be built without the CEO and so getting all the key stakeholders together is critical but what I mentioned above needs to be fed to the market (households, local businesses etc), not the guidelines; so people can FEEL the brand.

      A brand is embraced.

      I look forward to seeing the development. 

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.