BAA recently asked PR agencies to pitch for its account. A great honour you might think. One of the world’s leading companies asking you for your thoughts on how they can best present themselves. Thankfully, Lava wasn’t invited. Why thankfully? Because BAA wanted to charge agencies for the privilege – £1000, to be exact.
The use of pitches to decide which agency is best placed to work with a client is a time honoured tradition and part and parcel of the PR – design – social media – marketing world.
Pitching isn’t ideal.
In most cases the agency isn’t paid for the vast amount of time preparing a pitch or proposal requires. Research, creative sessions, writing and practicing takes time – a lot of time. Time which could be spent helping clients who are already paying the agency for their professional services and assistance.
Some organisations invite agencies into pitch, yet never appoint. Some organisations invite agencies into pitch, never appoint and then go on to use the ideas outlined in the presentations. Unfortunately, protecting ideas is incredibly difficult.
Very few organisations value the time it takes to prepare pitch presentations. I think we’ve only been paid once for the time we’ve invested in developing a proposal. We won the work and so never had to invoice. I hope the agencies we fought off received payment.
If organisations want to get the best out of a pitch process then yes, go out to lots of agencies and ask for their credentials documents. But then it’s time to shortlist and meet with the ones you like best; then select three or four of your favourites and give them a written brief, a budget and the opportunity to talk to you directly and in private; invite them in to present and offer to pay for their time – a £500 contribution will really make a difference.
The alternative, if ideas are to be protected, is for creative agencies to introduce non-disclosure agreements and pre-nups – but how will that work out? If relationships begin with one eye focused on how you are going to break up, will it really stand the test of time? Probably not.
One thing is for sure. If agencies have to buy the business or the chance to pitch, then it’s not going to develop into a relationship based on trust and understanding.

